In our family, we call these Penny’s Party Potatoes. I usually make them the night before a holiday dinner, but if I can get them done two days ahead, even better. I think the garlic flavor comes through a little more after the potatoes have had time to sit. And on Thanksgiving morning, it’s nice to open the fridge and see that dish already waiting for me.
I use my KitchenAid to mash the potatoes with cream cheese, sour cream, and butter. Then, just before baking, I poke little holes in the cold potatoes and pour a splash of cream or milk into them. That way, when I give the potatoes a stir in the oven, the cream is already down in the middle of the dish.
Ingredients
- 3–5 pounds potatoes, peeled and cubed
- 8 ounces cream cheese, softened
- ½ cup sour cream
- 8 tablespoons butter (1 stick)
- 1–2 teaspoons salt, to taste (if using garlic salt, taste before adding any extra salt)
- 2–4 teaspoons minced garlic or garlic seasoning, to taste (I like Tastefully Simple Garlic Garlic, but garlic powder or garlic salt also works)
- 1–2 teaspoons black pepper, to taste
- ¼–½ cup cream or milk, for baking day
How to make them
- Boil the potatoes. Place the cubed potatoes in a large pot, cover with salted water, and boil until a fork slips easily into a piece. Drain well.
- Mash in one batch. Add the warm potatoes, cream cheese, sour cream, and butter to your stand mixer bowl. Add your choice of garlic and start with the smaller amounts of salt and pepper. If you’re using garlic salt, leave out the extra salt for now. Mix on low just until the potatoes are as smooth as you like, then taste and adjust the seasoning.
- Cover and refrigerate. Spoon the potatoes into a shallow baking dish and cover. Refrigerate promptly, within two hours of cooking. I usually make mine the night before serving, though sometimes I make them two days ahead.
- Add the cream or milk. On serving day, heat the oven to 325°F. Use the handle of a spoon to poke little tunnels down into the cold potatoes. Pour ¼ cup of cream or milk into the tunnels, using up to ½ cup total if you like your potatoes a little looser. Cover the dish again before baking.
- Bake covered and stir occasionally. My potatoes usually take 1½–2 hours. I check them periodically, stirring the potatoes from the edges into the middle so they heat evenly, then cover them again. Start checking sooner if you used closer to 3 pounds or spread them in a wider dish. They’re ready when the center reaches 165°F. Give them one last stir before serving.
Optional additions: If you want to change them up, fold in a little onion powder or finish the potatoes with sliced green onions, shredded cheese or crumbled bacon.
From My Kitchen
I mash these potatoes in my KitchenAid. For baking day, I like a dish with a lid because I can give the potatoes a stir, pop the lid back on, and slide them back into the oven. The lid keeps the potatoes from getting dried out.
Affiliate disclosure: I may earn a small commission if you purchase through the links below, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.



